| Many
of the seismic upgrades we see during our inspections are improperly
installed. Homeowners are falling victim to contractors who charge
excessive fees to install earthquake resistance systems that will
perform poorly when the next big earthquake comes.
Earthquake
retrofit components fall into two primary categories: metal connectors
and wood bracing panels. The steel anchor bolt, which is the original
seismic component, was used in a few homes in the 1920s and 1930s,
and became a standard requirement in the 1940s. Anchor bolts are
designed to prevent horizontal movement and are intended to keep
the house from sliding off the foundation.
Modern
construction standards call for bolting at least every six feet,
with bolts within the last 12 inches of each piece of sill plate.
Buildings with more than one story, or on hillsides, may need anchor
bolts every four feet. Anchor bolts can be added to existing foundations
if the concrete is strong enough to hold them. Many older foundations
have poor quality concrete, which will break apart when bolts are
installed or when stressed by an earthquake. Wedge type anchor bolts
were the standard retrofit device for many years. Wedge anchors
expand against the concrete and may loosen with time and periodic
vibration. Most engineers now prefer bolts set into epoxy. Epoxy
bolts do not place a strain on the concrete until the actual seismic
event and are especially useful if the concrete does not have full
strength. Epoxy-set bolts have even been used in some brick foundations.
New
foundations may also have L-shaped brackets called "hold downs,"
which are bolted down into the foundation and horizontally to the
vertical framing. Hold-downs are designed to prevent vertical upward
movement and are especially effective if secured to the framing
at plywood bracing panels or "shear panels." The weakest
part of the building is usually the short, or "cripple,"
walls that support the lower floor framing. Most older buildings
rely on diagonal blocking or let-in braces to keep these walls vertical.
Blocks and braces are no longer considered adequate and the new
standard calls for plywood bracing panels, often referred to as
"shear panels." Properly installed bracing panels can
significantly reduce the potential for structural failure. These
panels make the building stiffer, and may actually cause more interior
damage, such as plaster cracking and falling furniture, in a well-braced
house during a minor or moderate earthquake.
Life
safety is not considered by some experts to be a primary concern
because serious injury or death in single-family, wood-framed residential
structures is very rare during an earthquake. The primary purpose
of seismic reinforcement is to keep the house from becoming a total
loss when the big quake comes.
The
plywood or OSB (Oriented Strand Board) bracing panels should be
properly nailed and supported by framing on all four edges. The
nails should be no more than six inches apart and ideally no more
than three inches apart. The nails should not be over-driven, which
would weaken the connection. Screws should not be used, as they
may break off under stress. Metal straps are now available to reinforce
the connection between the bracing panels and the floor framing
above. These are easy to install and can substantially increase
the strength of the system.
Simple,
single-story structures can usually be significantly reinforced by
a qualified earthquake contractor for about $3,000 to $5,000. Two-story
buildings and houses on hillsides should be examined by a qualified
engineer to determine the most effective use of the seismic upgrade
dollar. It may be necessary in some cases to replace old, deteriorated
foundations in order to install an effective seismic system. It is
not wise to spend too much money on your seismic reinforcements. You
may not be able to recoup your expenses when you sell the house. In
many cases the best strategy it be to make modest improvements and
to buy earthquake insurance. Home buyers today are much more concerned
about foundation strength than they were a few years ago and a reasonable
amount of bolting and shear bracing is probably a good investment.
|